Saturday, August 27, 2011

He followed his imam in Taraweeh to pray ‘Isha’, then he followed him again for the last two rak’ahs


I missed ‘Isha’ prayer and the imam began to pray Taraweeh. I joined the prayer with the imam with the intention of praying ‘Isha’. The imam prayed two rak’ahs then he said the salaam, and I remained sitting but did not say the salaam. When he stood up to pray again I stood up with him and completed my ‘Isha’ prayer with him. Is the way I offered this prayer correct? If it was not correct, what should I do?.

Praise be to Allaah.

The scholars differed concerning the ruling on offering an
obligatory prayer behind an imam who is offering a naafil prayer. We have
quoted some of the scholarly opinions on this matter in the answer to
question number 79136.  

Imam al-Shafaa’i and Ibn al-Mundhir are of the view that this
is permissible, and this is also narrated from Ahmad. The scholars of the
Standing Committee and Shaykh Ibn Baaz also favoured this view, and in the
question mentioned above we quoted him as saying that it is permissible,
namely praying ‘Isha’ behind one who is praying Taraweeh, and that the
person praying behind him should complete his prayer on his own after the
imam says the salaam. 

As for what the questioner did, sitting after the imam said
the salaam so that he could follow him in the next two rak’ahs of Taraweeh,
there are two scholarly opinions concerning the one who starts his prayer on
his own -- can he follow an imam who is leading a congregation? Some of them
said that this is not allowed and some of them said that it is valid. 

Shaykh al-‘Uthaymeen did not give a definitive opinion
concerning this action and he said, after stating that it is permissible for
one who is offering an obligatory prayer to pray behind one who is offering
a naafil prayer, which includes it being permissible to offer ‘Isha’ prayer
behind one who is praying Taraweeh: 

Rather what I am not sure about is their waiting for the imam
until he starts the next two rak’ahs and completing the prayer with him.
This is what I am not sure about, because the Messenger (blessings and peace
of Allah be upon him) said: “Whatever you catch up with, pray, and whatever you miss, complete it.” The apparent meaning is that a person should complete what he missed with his imam on his own, meaning that he should not
wait until the imam starts another prayer. Rather we say: When the imam says
the salaam at the end of the prayer in which you caught up with him, then
complete the prayer and do not wait until he starts another prayer. End

Fataawa Noor ‘ala al-Darb (Tape
no. 15, side B) 

Al-Nawawi thought it more likely that this is permissible, as
he said: 

If he prays ‘Isha’ behind Taraweeh, that is permissible, and
when the imam says the salaam, he should stand up to do the remaining two
rak’ahs. It is better for him to complete them on his own. If the imam gets
up to do two more rak’ahs of Taraweeh, he should form the intention to
follow him again in his two rak’ahs. There are two opinions as to whether it
is permissible for one who started the prayer on his own to then intend to
follow the imam. The more correct view is that it is valid. End quote. 

Al-Majmoo’ Sharh al-Muhadhdhab,

Based on this, the prayer was valid and you do not have to
repeat it, but it is better -- in the future -- to complete your prayer on
your own and not to join with the imam again. 

The brother who asked this question does not have to repeat the prayer or to repeat the two rak’ahs. The ‘Isha’ prayer that he offered behind the imam who was praying Taraweeh is valid. But we think that it is better for him to complete what remains for him of his prayer on his own. But if he follows the last two rak’ahs with the imam again, that is permissible. 

And Allah knows best.

No comments: